Lesson 7 · Part 2: The Player
Stories and Communities
Why the best story in a game is the one the player makes, and how a game grows into a community that keeps it alive.
Stories and Communities
Ask a friend about a film they saw last week, and they’ll tell you what the characters did. Now ask them about the family Monopoly game that went on until two in the morning, and listen to the grammar change. “So I’m down to my last forty dollars, my brother owns everything, and I land on Free Parking, and suddenly there’s five hundred in the middle because Mom’s been playing house rules for twenty years and never told anyone.”
They’re telling you what they did. Nobody wrote that story. It came out of some rules, a situation, and a handful of people making choices around a table. This level is about stories like that, and about what happens when enough people share them: the game stops being something you play and becomes somewhere you belong.
Two ways to learn more than one life can teach
Let’s start a long way back, with a problem every creature has. You’re in here, and the world is out there. All you know of it directly is what’s reached your own eyes and ears and hands. Call that your bubble of experience. It’s small. One life in one place just doesn’t supply enough material to build a reliable mental model of how everything works.
People found two ways around the limit. The first is the toy experience: a small pretend version of something real, tried out safely and then applied to the real thing. That’s play, as Level 1 defined it. The second is to borrow from someone else’s bubble. Picture an early human coming back to the cave and saying a tiger nearly got them down by the river. You weren’t at the river, and you’ll still be careful the next time you go. That’s story.
Both of these are, at heart, ways of learning. They’re the two tricks our species has for knowing more than one life can teach us, which may be exactly why we love them so much.
Stories make play, and play makes stories
The two are related, and each one can produce the other.
A good story breaks down into parts: characters, places, objects. Hand a kid action figures from a favorite film and those parts become a playset. Within ten minutes the heroes are having adventures the film never showed, and the villain has somehow become friends with the dog.
It works the other way round too. A game that gives people freedom throws off stories as a byproduct. That’s what your friend was telling you about Monopoly. We’ll call it a player story: the account of what happened to one player in one game, caused by their own choices. Every pickup soccer game produces a few. “Remember when Sam scored with his face?”
“I’ve always thought that the coolest stories are always coming from the players.”
The opposite is backstory, the material a designer writes ahead of time: what the world is, who lives there, what happened before you arrived. It’s nice to have. It sets the stage and hands the player nouns to work with. But plenty of game designers secretly want to be novelists, and it’s worth resisting. The designer builds the stage, and the player puts on the play.
Level 4 explained why the player’s version hits harder. A written story works through empathy: you feel along with a character. A player’s story works through agency. You were responsible for everything in it, so it draws on a different emotional palette, one with pride and guilt and “I can’t believe I did that” in it.
What happens when players get a pen
Near the end of making The Sims, a computer game about little people living in a house, Will Wright’s team brought in testers and sat back to watch. The testers played in pairs and spent the whole session telling each other what was going on, adding motives and details the game knew nothing about. So at the last minute the team added a feature: grab a few pictures from your game, write a line under each, and publish the result as a little illustrated album online with one click.
It took off. The first albums were jokes and superheroes, as you’d expect. Then they changed. One came from a woman who’d left an abusive relationship and wanted to encourage others in the same spot. Another was about a miserable last year of school. One was a long, heartfelt complaint about a particular coffee shop. These were mostly people who’d never have written anything down. They had things to say and no outlet, and the game became one. That’s self-expression: putting something of yourself into the world, using a game’s pieces as your vocabulary.
Readers could comment on the albums and rate them, and that turned out to matter enormously. For someone who’d never once been told they were creative, five strangers saying “that was really cool” was enough to send them back to make something far more ambitious. A tiny bit of recognition produced a huge amount of effort. Hold on to that, because it’s what keeps whole communities running.
Creative leverage
For most of history, getting a picture out of your head and in front of other people took years of practice. Paint-by-numbers kits, photo booths, and karaoke machines all chip away at that a little: they do the hard part, and you supply the meaning. Computers can chip away a lot. The name for it is creative leverage, a tool that turns a small amount of skill and effort into a big, polished result.
That’s user-generated content: parts of a game made by the people who play it. It gives a game far more variety than its makers could afford, and every contributor gets a stake in the result. Tabletop players have done it forever, too, with house rules, homemade expansions, and hand-painted pieces.
Sometimes players go further than anyone expected. Once games gave people control of a camera and some characters, some started using games as cheap film studios, staging and recording scenes to tell stories of their own. That’s machinima, from “machine” and “cinema,” and nobody designed it. Players just noticed that a game could double as a puppet theater.
From “I play this” to “I make things for this”
Meet a stranger at a wedding, and within three minutes they know where you live, what you do, that you run on Sundays, and which sports team ruins your weekends. Those facts are how we tell people who we are. Picture them as rings around you: the innermost ring holds what makes you you, the middle one holds your groups and hobbies, and the outer one holds the big world everyone shares. A game that lands in one of those rings has become part of someone’s player identity. Level 4 described the extension of self inside a game, when “he went to bed” turns into “I went to bed.” This is the same move carried out into life.
Nobody starts in the inner rings. Everyone arrives at a hobby the same way, as a casual visitor having a look. Most people wander off again, which is fine. The ones who stay start to move, and the route they take deeper in is their player trajectory.
Take model railways. Someone buys a little starter set for the kids. A year later they’re collecting a particular old railway line’s engines. Then they’re building scenery, with hand-painted trees and a tiny pub. Then they’re writing the club newsletter and running the Christmas show. Trading cards, knitting, and birdwatching all work the same way. Each step takes a bit more time and skill, and each one changes how the person sees themselves.
The useful thing for a designer is that a trajectory can be built. Each stage needs a doorway to the next: something a casual player can do in five minutes that’s a half-step toward collecting, and something a collector can do that’s a half-step toward making.
A pyramid held up by its base
Stack those stages and you get a pyramid: lots of casual players at the bottom, fewer collectors, fewer makers, and a handful of organizers at the very top. Think of it like a food chain in a pond, which is why we call it community ecology.
In a food chain, energy flows up. In a community, what flows up is recognition: attention, praise, reputation. The casual players are the ones saying “her stuff is the best” and “that club’s show is brilliant.” That’s the fuel. Most makers aren’t paid. They like being known for what they make. Meanwhile, the things they make flow back down: new scenery, new decks, new stories, which give the casual players more reasons to stick around, which keeps the base wide.
Cut either flow and the whole thing wobbles. Without an audience, makers stop making. Without new things arriving, the audience drifts off. Every hobby club has someone who runs the newsletter, organizes the meetups, and hardly plays anymore. They aren’t there for the game now. They’re there for the people, and their place among them.
Try it · Pocket Game, step 7Tell it, then make it yours
Play a round of your Pocket Game, with someone or against yourself. As soon as it ends, tell what happened as a story in exactly three sentences, out loud or on paper, using “I.” Then add one way for a player to put their own mark on the game before play starts: choose and name their own piece, draw a symbol on a paper token, or arrange their side however they like. Play again and listen for the moment someone says “my” about a piece. If nobody does, make the mark bigger.
Carry forward: Build the stage, hand over the props, and give people a way in and a way to be noticed.