Lesson 6 · Part 2: The Player
Why We Keep Playing
What people want, why prizes are the weakest way to keep them playing, and how discovery, self-set goals, and a bit of flattery do the heavy lifting.
Why We Keep Playing
Two kids are learning the piano. The first one has a chart on the fridge: a gold star for every twenty minutes of practice, and ten stars buys a trip for ice cream. The second one heard a tune in a cartoon and has spent most of Saturday at the keyboard hunting for it one note at a time, getting it wrong, and refusing to come to lunch.
Both of them are practicing. But take the chart off the fridge and the first kid stops within a week. You can’t take anything away from the second one, because nobody gave her anything in the first place. Games run on both kinds of wanting, and a big part of a designer’s job is telling them apart.
What people want before they ever meet your game
Here’s a slightly humbling fact about designing games. Computers get faster every year. Human brains are running pretty much the same model they were a hundred years ago. Whatever you build has to plug into wants that were installed long before your game showed up.
Psychologists have drawn lots of maps of those wants. One of the best known comes from Abraham Maslow, who stacked them in a pyramid. At the bottom are the needs of the body: food, sleep, warmth, safety. Above those come company and belonging, then respect, and at the very top the urge to become whatever you’re capable of becoming. The lower layers shout loudest. It’s hard to worry about your reputation when you’re starving.
You don’t have to treat Maslow as gospel. Think of each theory as a tool in a toolbox, handy for some jobs and useless for others. In this course we’ll use the phrase needs and motives for the wants that push behavior, whether they belong to a real person or a pretend one. Every player arrives with a full set. Your game can hook into them. It can’t replace them.
You’ve seen the same wiring outside games. Anyone who has looked after a dog knows the daily needs (walk, food, water, attention) and also knows that the dog, somehow, became the reason they get up early and meet the neighbors.
Rewards get handed out, reasons get brought along
A reward is something the game hands the player for doing what the designer hoped they’d do: points, stars, a new level, a shiny new ability. Rewards are genuinely useful. They mark progress, nudge players toward corners they might miss, and let you set the pace. Think of the stamp card at a café. Nobody loves coffee because of the card, but it does steer which café you walk into.
The trouble is that designers lean on rewards way too hard. A game that pays out constantly starts to feel mechanical. The player can see the machinery, and the prizes start feeling like that chart on the fridge.
What keeps people at something for months is a different engine. Psychologists call it intrinsic motivation: wanting to do a thing for its own sake. It might be the pleasure of building, or a skill you can feel getting sharper, or the fun of beating your sister. Whatever it is, the wanting starts inside the player. People who are hooked invent their own targets without being asked. “I’m going to finish this jigsaw before dinner.” “I’m going to get the whole crossword without looking anything up.” Back in Level 1 we said a goal state can come from the player. This is where those goals come from.
There’s a simple test that separates the two. Take the reward away. If the player keeps going, there was a reason underneath. If they stop, the reward was all you had.
None of this means rewards are bad. A well-placed one tells a nervous beginner they’re on the right track, and a rare one can mark a moment worth remembering. The mistake is building the whole game out of them. Work out first what’s satisfying about the activity itself, then add rewards where people need a signpost.
The joy of finding it yourself
That garden points at the strongest reward of all: the one players think they came up with themselves. Discovery is the pleasure of finding something, working something out, or getting somewhere you weren’t supposed to go. Remember the thrill of finding a shortcut through the park that nobody told you about? Or the moment a cryptic crossword clue suddenly clicks? Nobody handed you that. It feels like yours.
You design for discovery by holding things back. Leave some corners closed, and now and then open a gate a crack so the player glimpses how much more is in there. This works for rules as well as places. A player who figures out on their own that two moves combine into something clever will value that trick far more than any ability the game announces with a fanfare, even if the designer planned the combination all along.
An Easter egg is discovery at its purest: something hidden purely for the fun of finding it, with no effect on winning at all. The name comes from the egg hunt, and it works on exactly the same principle.
Make it about them
Wright has a rule he offers as a twist on an old showman’s line about the public:
“No game designer ever went wrong by overestimating the narcissism of their players.”
It’s a joke with a serious idea tucked inside, which we’ll call player narcissism. The more a game is about the player, celebrates the player, and puts the player at the center of its little universe, the more the player tends to like it. That’s not an insult. It describes all of us. We look up when someone says our name. We read the birthday card twice when it’s got our name written in icing on the cake beside it.
In practice it means remembering what the player did and showing it back to them. Let them name things. Put what they built somewhere they can admire it. Tell them they’re the mayor.
It also means leaving room for players who cheerfully ignore your plans. Watch kids with a box of Monopoly money and you’ll often find them running a toy shop instead of playing Monopoly. Chess pieces become a royal family with a lot of drama. This sideways play has a name: orthogonal creativity. “Orthogonal” means at right angles, so this is play that moves across the game’s measure of success instead of up it. It doesn’t win anything. Some players give themselves to it completely and never come back to the game loops you laid out. Their reasons are entirely their own, and they’re often your most devoted players.
Not everyone at the table wants the same thing
Picture a family board game night. One person is counting their money every turn. One is reading every card in the box to see what’s in there. One is mostly there to chat and tease. And one is plotting, with real joy, how to ruin everybody else’s evening. Same game, four completely different reasons to sit down.
Designers have names for these patterns: player types, rough categories that sort people by what they want from a game. The best-known scheme comes from designer Richard Bartle, who described four: achievers (out for goals and trophies), explorers (out to see what’s there), socializers (out for the company), and killers (out to impose themselves on other players, the plotter at your games night).
The exact list matters less than the habit of asking who’s actually sitting in front of you. It matters most when you start measuring how people play, which Level 18 covers under metrics. An explorer who has wandered for an hour and never finished a level isn’t failing at your game. An achiever who never touched the decorating tools didn’t miss the point. Different types need different yardsticks.
Two quick warnings. Real people are mixtures, and they shift between types depending on their mood. And the types need each other. A show-off with nobody to show off to is just a person alone in a room.
When getting what you wanted makes more to do
Rewards have one more weakness. Once the player has the prize, they need another one, and you’re stuck supplying them forever.
The neat trick is to let success create the next challenge. Anyone who’s bought a bigger house knows how this goes: more rooms to clean, a garden to mow, a roof that leaks in new and exciting places. Houseplants need watering. A second dog doesn’t halve your walks. Every nice thing you collect comes with its own little upkeep, a sort of time bomb that goes off later as a chore. If you played Five Needs, you’ve already felt it.
You met this back in Level 5 as the complexity ramp, where the game gets harder because the player asked for it. Seen from here, it does a second job too. The player never runs out of reasons to keep going, because getting what they wanted changed the problem in front of them. Nothing was handed out, and they’ve got more to do than before.
Try it · Pocket Game, step 6No score, one secret
Play a round of your Pocket Game without keeping score of any kind. No points, no winner. Afterward, write down what you still wanted to do while you were playing: stack higher, flick straighter, annoy your opponent. That list is where your game’s reasons live, so check whether your rules give them enough room. Then hide one secret. It could be a rule on a folded slip that only gets read when something rare happens, or a piece with a mark on its underside. It mustn’t help anyone win.
Carry forward: Rewards can point the way, but people stay for reasons of their own.