Lesson 21 · Part 6: Sharing It

Where Games Live

Where a game is played, who it's played by, how it pays its way, and a few guesses about where games are heading.

11 min read

Where Games Live

Take one deck of cards to three places. At a bus stop, two strangers play a quick hand of something they can drop the second the bus pulls up. At a holiday dinner, three generations play a loud game whose rules get argued about every single year. In a casino, people play in near silence, for money, under a dealer’s eye. Fifty-two identical pieces of cardboard. Almost nothing else is the same.

Ask a new designer where their game will be played, and they’ll usually name a device: phones, a console, a board. The deck of cards suggests the device is the least of it. Who’s holding the cards, and what the room around them expects, shaped those three games far more than the cardboard did.

Three platforms at once

In everyday speech, a platform is the thing a game runs on. For a video game that’s a phone, a console, or a computer. For everything else it might be a deck of cards, a chessboard, a pub table, a backyard with a ball, or a classroom with thirty kids and one whiteboard.

Will Wright likes to count three platforms and treat them as one. The first is the technology, which is the stuff the game is made of. The second is the culture: the country, the community, and the room the game is played in, and what those people expect a game to be. The third is the person: their age, their habits, how much time they’ve got, whether they play alone or with the whole family watching.

Notice which one is easiest to change. A popular card game can be printed in any language and sold in any shop. A hit video game eventually gets moved to almost every kind of device. The technology is mostly a question of where to start. The other two don’t loosen with time. A party game built for a noisy room of friends doesn’t become a quiet solo game just because it’s now on a phone. Level 18 called the people you’re designing for your target audience. They’re as much a part of the platform as the cardboard is.

Small teams again, and games for the gaps

For a while, making a video game looked like it needed a hundred people and a mountain of money. Then app stores and cheap online publishing turned that upside down. A handful of people can now make something and put it in front of the public in a weekend. Tabletop went the same way, with crowdfunding and print-on-demand letting a single designer print a few hundred copies of their own card game.

The hard part moved. Getting a game out became easy, and getting anyone to notice it became the challenge. Still, for a designer, the big win is speed. You can learn from real players quickly and change direction cheaply. Level 17 was all about iteration. When each change of direction costs a fortune, you make very few. When it costs a weekend, you can make lots. Start on whatever platform lets you try ideas most cheaply. Right now, for you, that’s probably the paper prototype on your table.

Phones brought something else that almost nobody saw coming: games for the little gaps in a day. Call it interstitial play: very short play sessions squeezed in between other things, like a bus ride, a queue, or the time it takes a kettle to boil. This isn’t new, by the way. People were doing crosswords on the train and playing solitaire at the kitchen table long before phones. Phones just put a game in everybody’s pocket, including plenty of people who’d never call themselves gamers.

For a designer, the interesting part is that one game can now live across several moments of someone’s day. A two-minute turn on the bus, a longer session on the sofa, a planning session at a desk. That asks something specific of the design. The shortest game loop has to finish inside the smallest gap, and being interrupted halfway can’t be a punishment.

Money comes second

A business model is how a game pays its way. There are lots of them, and they’re older than you’d think. Board games are sold once, in a box. Arcades charged a coin per play. Pub quizzes charge an entry fee per team. Collectible card games sell you the box and then sell you more cards. Video games add a few more: pay once, play free and buy extras inside, pay a monthly subscription, or some mix of those.

The tempting move is to pick the model first and design around it. Wright argues for the opposite order:

“I think in terms of let’s design something that’s going to be just so damn cool that people are going to want it.”

Will Wright

The experience comes first. Once it exists and you can see who it draws in, look at how those particular people are used to paying for fun. Some expect to buy a box and own it forever. Others expect to try something free for hours before spending a penny. It’s far easier to bend a design toward a model its audience is comfortable with than to pick one in advance and force it on people who dislike it.

This is a point about order. The model still shapes the design in the end. A game sold once and a game that’s free with extras for sale get tuned very differently. The audience’s habits should make the choice, and you learn those habits by watching who turns up.

An interface you stop noticing

Every platform has its own way for players to act: cards you hold, pieces you push, dice you throw, a touchscreen, buttons, a phone you can tilt. The best ones share a quality. A transparent interface is one the player stops noticing, so their attention rests on the game and their agency feels direct. Nobody playing tennis thinks about the racket. Nobody writing a letter thinks about the pencil.

Use whatever helps the controls disappear, but don’t build a whole game around one device’s special trick. A game that only works if you tilt a phone is lost on someone using a tablet they’d rather keep flat on the table. Treat special features as a bonus on top of a design that works without them.

They can be a lovely bonus, though. Wright had played plenty of computer racing games with a keyboard and found them fine. The first time he played one on a tablet, he held the whole thing like a steering wheel and turned it, and he liked it so much more that he started preferring racing games there. Same game. The controls had vanished, and that changed how the whole thing felt.

A few guesses about what’s next

This is the part of the level most likely to be wrong, so let’s be honest about that up front. In the late 2010s, Wright made some guesses about where games were heading. Read them as one experienced designer’s predictions. You get the advantage of reading them later than he made them.

He’d played a fair amount of virtual reality (headsets that fill your whole view with a computer-made world) and enjoyed it. But however immersive it was, he never wanted to stay in for long, and he suspected nearly everyone has a limit. Being sealed off from the room around you is uncomfortable in its own way. So he expected more from augmented reality, which layers a game onto the world you can still see, ideally one that knows where you are and what you’re up to.

Look at how he reasoned. He barely talks about the hardware. He talks about comfort, embarrassment, and how long a person wants to be cut off from the people around them. Those are the culture and person parts of the platform, and those are the parts that decide things.

His biggest guess was about artificial intelligence, and not smarter opponents. He meant a game that pays attention to you. It watches what you do, works out what you enjoy and what you avoid, and reshapes itself around what it learns. Call it an adaptive game.

This idea is much older than computers. A good game master running a tabletop role-playing game does it all evening: they notice who’s bored and who’s lit up, and they nudge the story accordingly. A parent making up a bedtime game does it without thinking. Level 3 said every designer works with two computers, the machine and the player’s head, and all of player-centered design is guessing about people you’ll never meet. An adaptive game moves the guessing inside the game, live, for each person.

Wright didn’t describe this with simple excitement. He worried that something tuned so precisely to one person could be very hard to put down, and admitted he almost wished we’d avoid building it, while knowing we won’t. You already have the words for his worry. Level 5 showed you flow, and Level 6 showed the difference between a reward and intrinsic motivation. A game that can tune those for each player is a powerful tool. Whether it’s tuned for the player’s good or for the player’s hours is going to be decided by designers. You might be one of them.

Hold it loosely

For a long time the future of video games was easy to read: a new generation of consoles every five years or so, and everybody knew the next one was coming. That steady rhythm is gone. Five years from now, the most popular way to play might be something nobody has heard of yet, and the same goes for whatever’s on your café table.

So don’t marry a platform, an approach, or a philosophy. Look far enough ahead to guess where things might be in a few years, and no further. The habit of iteration works for a career as well as a game: take short steps and look up often. And keep one thing fixed. Devices change every year. Players’ heads don’t.

Try it · Pocket Game, step 21Three platforms and two minutes

On one card, write your Pocket Game’s three platforms. Thing: what it’s physically made of and where it can be played. Culture: what kind of group would play it, and what they’d expect. Person: one specific player, with an age and a reason to play. Then design the two-minute version. What can someone start and finish in two minutes, ideally one-handed, and what carries over to next time? Play that version three times in a row to check it’s worth doing again.

Carry forward: Name the person and the room before you name the device, let your audience tell you how they want to pay, and keep your predictions in pencil.