Lesson 11 · Part 3: The Machinery
Systems and Possibility Space
How games hold everything that could happen, from hand-written branches to open systems, and the three kinds of part a system is built from.
Systems and Possibility Space
You’re ten years old, reading a choose-your-own-adventure book with one finger jammed at page 12 in case the cave goes badly. To enter the cave, turn to page 7. To climb the hill, turn to page 20. By the end of the afternoon you’ve found every ending, and you could count them on your fingers and toes. Somebody sat at a desk and wrote every one of them.
Now get out a chess set. Nobody wrote the games of chess. There are more possible games than there are atoms in the universe (truly, people have done the arithmetic), and every one of them comes out of a board, thirty-two pieces, and a page or two of rules.
The book and the chess set are both games. This level is about what makes them so different, and about how to build the second kind.
Every game is a space
Picture every situation a game could ever be in: every position of every piece, every score, every arrangement of the world. That whole collection is the game’s possibility space. Playing a game is a walk through it. Each move takes you from one spot in the space to another.
Tic-tac-toe has a tiny possibility space. You’d walked all of it by about age nine, which is exactly why you stopped playing. Chess has a finite space too, but it’s so enormous that nobody will ever finish exploring it.
In both, each move leads to a handful of possible next moves, and each of those leads to more. Draw that out and you get a branching tree: the opening position is the trunk, and every possible game is a path out to the tip of a twig. You met this shape in Level 2 as the design tree, where it mapped a designer’s choices. Here it maps the player’s.
Three ways to build a space
Write every branch. That’s the adventure book. Early computer games worked this way too. You get total control over what the player sees, and you pay for it in effort, because every branch has to be written by hand. The world is exactly as big as the writing.
Build rooms with doors. Think of an escape room with several chambers. Inside each room you’re free to poke around, try things, and combine clues however you like. But you can’t get to the next room until you’ve opened the lock. That’s a gated experience: little islands of freedom with gates between them. Inside an island the player chooses. Between islands the designer decides the order. Lots of puzzle games, adventure games, and treasure hunts are built like this, and it’s a good way to combine freedom with a planned journey.
Build a system. This is how sandbox games, and plenty of board games, work. The space is far too big for anyone to map, so the designer stops writing outcomes and builds a system instead: a set of parts that affect one another according to rules, so the whole thing produces situations as it runs.
A fish tank is a system. Fish, plants, water, light, and food all push on each other. Nobody scripts what happens in a fish tank on Tuesday. You stock it, set it going, and it carries on without you. A kitchen at dinner rush is a system. So is a playground at break time, with its games forming and splitting and re-forming without anybody in charge.
Each of the three approaches is a trade off. Hand-written branches give you precision and cost you size. Systems give you size and variety and cost you control. Gates sit in between. Plenty of games mix them, with a system inside each room, or a hand-written story laid on top of an open world.
What it’s made of, and what it does
To build a system, you need a way to think about its insides. A handy method is to ask two questions about anything, which this course files under structure and dynamics.
Structure is what a thing is made of. A tree has a trunk, branches, and leaves. Dynamics is what happens to it over time. A tree grows, drops its leaves in autumn, can be cut down, can be burned for firewood. In the game grammar from Level 8, structure supplies the nouns and dynamics supplies the verbs.
Structure comes in three handy flavors, and a little town makes them easy to picture.
- Agents are separate things, each with its own state, that act or get acted on. The people in the town are agents. So are the cars, the dogs, and the pigeons. A shop counts too: it doesn’t walk around, but it has its own identity and its own numbers.
- Networks are things joined by links, where what matters is who’s connected to whom. The roads between the town’s crossroads form a network. So do its water pipes, its friendships, and its bus routes.
- Layers are quantities spread out over space, like a weather map laid over the town. How noisy is each street? How expensive is the land? How much litter is there? A layer has a value everywhere, and the value shades gradually from place to place.
Dynamics can run across any of the three. Things spread, grow, cluster, and get shared out. Spreading alone shows why the pairing matters. A rumor spreads through a network of friends, hopping link to link and completely missing anyone who isn’t connected. Smoke spreads across a layer, rolling outward evenly and paying no attention to the roads. A cold spreads through agents who happen to bump into each other. The verb is the same in every case, and the behavior is completely different.
That gives you a simple recipe for inventing a mechanic: pick a structure, pick a dynamic. Fire spreading across a layer of dry grass. Shoppers sorting themselves among market stalls. Gossip racing through a school. Every pairing is a mechanic waiting to happen.
Hills in the fog
A huge space is no use if every player ends up in the same corner of it. Once you’ve built a system, part of your job is giving people reasons to explore different regions of it.
Here’s a picture that helps. Imagine a game where you can chase two kinds of success: making friends, or making money. Lean all the way into one and you end up stuck. You’re rich and lonely, or popular and broke, and doing more of the same thing doesn’t help. The best results come from balancing both.
That stuck spot has a name. A local maximum is a place where every small step makes things worse, so it feels like the top, even though a higher peak stands somewhere else. Imagine climbing a hill in thick fog. You reach a spot where the ground slopes down in every direction, so you plant your flag. You can’t see the mountain across the valley. To get higher, you’d have to walk down first, and that feels completely wrong.
Designing a possibility space is a bit like landscaping. You decide where the peaks are and how many there should be. Each peak is a goal state somebody might choose. Then you watch where people actually end up and adjust the game’s numbers, which is called tuning, until more than one hill is worth climbing.
One last trick: draw it. A gated game draws naturally as dots joined by lines. An open one looks like a landscape with peaks and valleys. A game you can’t draw at all is usually a game you don’t understand yet. The same goes for players: if something in your game feels too complicated, find a way to show it, and people will understand it with their eyes instead of their arithmetic.
Try it · Pocket Game, step 11Map it
Take a sheet of paper and draw your Pocket Game’s possibility space, roughly. Is it a tree of choices, a string of rooms with doors, or an open field? Mark where a game starts and two or three places it can end. Then label the parts. Circle each agent (pieces that act or get acted on). Draw lines for any network (what connects to what). Shade any layer (something that varies across the table, like safe ground and dangerous ground). If one of the three is missing, jot down what the game might gain if you added it.
Carry forward: Build parts that make things happen, then shape the space they open so there’s more than one hill worth climbing.