Lesson 10 · Part 3: The Machinery
Luck, Skill, and Fairness
Where dice belong, why a move that always wins ruins a game, and what makes losing feel fair.
Luck, Skill, and Fairness
Here’s a dice game you can play right now if you’ve got one die. It’s an old folk game usually called Pig. On your turn, you roll as many times as you like, adding up the numbers as you go. Stop whenever you want and bank the total. But if you roll a 1, you lose everything you’ve rolled that turn and pass the die along. First to 100 wins.
Play a few turns and you’ll notice something odd. You’re rolling a die, the most purely lucky object ever made, and yet you keep making decisions. Roll again with 18 points on the line? What if your friend is about to win? Somehow a game of pure chance has become a game about nerve. This level is about that mix: how much luck to put in a game, where to put it, and how to keep the whole thing feeling fair.
Dice and chessboards
Chance means some outcomes are settled by luck. You can shift the odds, but you can’t dictate the result. Its opposite is determinism, where the same action in the same situation always gives the same result. Move a chess knight and it lands exactly where you put it, every single time.
Games sit all along the line between the two. Snakes and Ladders is pure chance: you never make a decision, which is why adults play it mostly with small children and mostly out of love. Chess has no chance at all, which is why it can feel brutal: if you lost, the other person simply outplayed you. Most games live somewhere in between. Backgammon, poker, and Scrabble all mix luck with skill, and each mix gives the game its personality.
Luck isn’t the enemy of a good game. A pinch of it lets a beginner beat an expert once in a while, which keeps both of them coming back. It shakes up situations so the same game doesn’t play out the same way twice. And it gives everyone a dignified excuse. (“I’d have won if I hadn’t drawn those tiles.”) The design question is never “luck or no luck?” It’s where the luck should live.
Keep the player’s hands dependable
One good rule of thumb: keep the player’s own actions deterministic, and put chance out in the world, among the things nobody expects to control.
Think about what people expect. If you throw a ball at a target and your aim is perfect, you expect to hit it. If the ball randomly swerved off course one time in five, that would feel like a betrayal. But nobody expects to control the weather at a picnic. Rain is luck, and you deal with it.
Will Wright describes using exactly this split when he designed SimCity, a computer game about running a city. Fires in the city are partly random. Building fire stations doesn’t stop fires; it makes them less likely. Even a well-protected city can still burn now and then. Players accept that, because they can picture it happening in a real city, and they know what would have lowered the odds. He’s firm that the opposite, a game that seems to punish players for no reason, is close to unforgivable.
“The player always wants to feel like their success or failure is coming back to their agency.”
That’s what fairness means in design. Fair doesn’t mean easy. A fair game can be ferociously hard. It means that when you lose, you can trace the loss back to something you did, or something you chose not to do. Your agency is still in the story. The fire in the protected city passes the test. A sudden, unexplained disaster with no warning fails it. In Level 5 we asked for failure that’s interesting, and fairness is what makes that possible, because nobody learns from a loss they had no hand in. Clear feedback does a lot of the work here. If players can see what caused a loss, they can do something different next time.
The move that always wins
Here’s a game you’ve definitely played: tic-tac-toe. It’s fun for a while when you’re about six. Then, at some point, you discover that if both players play sensibly, every game ends in a draw. Nobody can win unless somebody makes a mistake. You stop playing, and you never really go back.
Tic-tac-toe didn’t get worse. You just found the bottom of it. A game stops being a game when there’s nothing left to decide, and the quickest way to get there is a dominant strategy: one option that’s the best choice no matter what anyone else does. Once players find it, every decision collapses into “do the obvious thing,” and the game is over even if the pieces are still on the table.
Now look at rock-paper-scissors. Rock beats scissors, scissors beats paper, paper beats rock. Every option beats one thing and loses to another, so there’s no move that’s always right. That little circle is about as pure an example of balance as you’ll find. A game is balanced when no option, side, or starting position is so much better than the others that everyone has to pick it. Balance keeps every choice on the table and worth thinking about. The usual way to get there is to make each option a trade off: great at one thing, worse at another.
Balance comes up everywhere once you start looking. In Go, the player who moves second gets a few bonus points, called komi, to make up for not going first. Golf and bowling give weaker players a handicap, so a beginner and a club champion can have a genuinely close game. None of those fixes remove skill. They just keep the outcome open long enough to be worth playing. And nobody gets balance right on the first try. It comes from tuning: play, adjust the numbers, play again.
Push your luck
Back to Pig for a second. Why is it fun when all you’re doing is rolling a die? Because every roll is a gamble you choose to take. The more you’ve built up, the more you stand to lose, and the more it hurts to stop. That’s risk and reward: a choice where the bigger payoff comes with a bigger chance of losing something.
Risk and reward is one of the most useful tools you’ll ever have, because it turns luck into a decision. Blackjack does it with “hit or stand.” A quiz show does it when it asks if you want to keep your winnings or go for the next question. In a playground game of tag, running out into the open to rescue a friend is a gamble too. The trick is to let the player choose how much risk to take. Then luck stops feeling like something that happens to them and starts feeling like something they bet on.
Luck behind the curtain
Chance is also a tool you use where the player can’t see. Imagine your game needs to know how much of a map is covered by forest, and the forests are wobbly blobs. You could try some fearsome geometry. Or you could throw a hundred darts at the map blindly and count how many land in a forest. If thirty-three of them do, the forest covers about a third of the map. That’s the Monte Carlo method: swapping one hard calculation for lots of cheap random tries. Computers are tireless dart throwers, which is why simulations lean on it so much.
And luck visits the designer, too. You build a rough version of something and it does a thing you never intended. A wonky rule produces a tactic nobody planned. A sloppy prototype makes everyone laugh in a way you’d never have thought to design. That’s serendipity, the happy accident, and it’s a real source of ideas. You can’t schedule it, but you can raise the odds: build things early, play them often, and pay attention when they misbehave.
Try it · Pocket Game, step 10Where luck lives
Look at your Pocket Game and ask where its luck lives. If there’s none, add a die or a coin flip to something out in the world, and leave the player’s own move alone. If there’s a lot, make one lucky thing dependable. Then go hunting for a move that always wins. Play against yourself and try to break your own game. If you find one, fix it by giving it a cost, a counter, or a risk. Last, add one gamble worth taking: a moment where a player can play it safe or push their luck for more.
Carry forward: Keep the player’s hands dependable, keep every option worth thinking about, and let players choose their own gambles.