Lesson 19 · Part 6: Sharing It
Pitch It
How to move the game in your head into someone else's head in thirty seconds, and when to stop talking.
Pitch It
It’s a rainy afternoon, and you’ve just invented a game for the kids next door. You gather them in the hallway. “Okay, so there are three teams, except one team is really one person, and you get points for touching the radiator, but only if nobody’s on the stairs, and also there’s a secret role, and I’ll explain the secret role later.” Two of them have wandered off by the word “radiator.” The third is now eating a crayon.
Then their older cousin wanders in and says, “The floor is lava, but the lava is rising.” Every kid is on the sofa before the sentence ends.
Same hallway, same kids, and a game that was arguably simpler. The cousin didn’t explain better. The cousin handed them something to play in their heads, right away. That’s what this level is about.
The listener is already playing
A pitch is a short description of your game, given to someone whose interest you need. It might be a friend, a teammate, someone with money, a journalist, or a stranger reading two lines on the back of a box. The stakes change. The thing that happens on the other side of the table doesn’t.
The moment someone hears “it’s a game where you…”, they start building it. They knock together a rough little version out of whatever you just said and take it for a spin. Level 3 called this a mental model. During a pitch, that imaginary version is the only game that exists, and the listener judges your idea by how much fun it is.
So a pitch is a game too. Actually, it’s the first one you design. It has an audience, it can be confusing or dull, and you can test it on people and tune it like anything else you make.
This explains a story designers love to tell about focus groups, the meetings where a room of people hears an idea described and gives their opinion. One studio described four game ideas to a room of players. The one everybody hated was a game about looking after a household of little people, which went on to become one of the best-selling computer games ever made (it’s called The Sims). The design was fine. The description was a bad game, because each listener had to build it in their head from a few sentences, and the version they built was dreadful.
Push the feeling, not the parts list
Most bad pitches are inventories. “There’s crafting, and a day-night cycle, and the enemies learn, and the art is probably watercolor.” Every item is true. None of it is playable, because nobody can play a list.
Go back to the moment before your idea had parts. Something about it made you sit up when it was still one sentence long. Find that again, and work out how to cause the same jolt in somebody else.
Ordinary empathy means feeling what someone else feels. A pitch needs the opposite trick, sometimes called reverse empathy: getting someone else to feel what you feel. In practice that means describing what it’s like to play. Mischievous? Powerful? Cozy? Clever? Say that. The systems can wait for the follow-up questions, and if the feeling lands, there’ll be plenty.
Start with the hook, and say “you”
The hook is the most intriguing thing about your game, said in one line, and it goes first. Usually it’s the subject, or the one thing you get to do here that you can’t do anywhere else. “The floor is lava, and it’s rising.” “It’s a game about gravity, and you choose which way is down.” “The city is flooding, and you’re selling houses in it.”
Notice how many of those have a “you” in them. Pitches go better the more they put the listener in the driver’s seat. “A world where traffic piles up” is a description. “You’re the mayor, and you decide where the roads go” is something to do, and the imaginary game in their head suddenly has verbs.
The classic mistake runs the other way: opening with the genre, the category label. “It’s a deck-builder.” “It’s a trivia game.” “It’s a side-scroller.” The label is accurate and it does real damage, because the listener files your idea in a small, familiar box and stops imagining. Everything you say afterward has to fight its way back out of the box. If your game belongs in a genre, fine. Say what’s fresh first, and where it’s shelved later, if at all.
Listeners will try to shelve your game anyway. “Oh, so it’s like Monopoly, but underwater?” That habit has a name: triangulation. People carry a map of every game they know, and they place a new one by finding the nearest landmarks. A game far from any landmark is hard to place, which is both a risk and an opening. You can use the habit on purpose. Name the nearest landmark yourself, then say which direction you walked away from it. That only works if they can picture why your direction is more fun.
Thirty seconds
Early in a project, your description of a game will probably run ten minutes. The goal is an elevator pitch: short enough to deliver between floors, somewhere from thirty seconds to a minute. Nobody has a formula for getting there. What works is saying it to real people, over and over.
So start early and aim low. The day you have an idea, tell a friend. Tell the next person you meet. Watch what they ask about, and where they change the subject. Your first telling will be bad, partly because the idea itself is still fuzzy. Saying it out loud is one of the ways it sharpens. By the time you pitch to someone who matters, the pitch should have been through dozens of people who don’t.
Wright’s best practice ground was oddly specific. At trade shows, journalists would come through his room one at a time, a new one every few minutes. When a journalist’s eyes dropped to their notes during one part, he trimmed it for the next one. When someone leaned in, the next person got more of that. By evening the pitch had evolved. Level 18 had a name for testing on a fresh person each time, a Kleenex test, and it works on words as well as games.
Most of the editing is cutting. Level 18 also gave you subtraction: the garden is finished when there’s nothing left to take out. Pitches work the same way. Every word that isn’t pulling its weight goes.
One reaction deserves special attention. If a listener asks “But why is that fun?”, don’t argue. If the pitch had worked, the game would already be fun in their imagination and they’d never have asked. Treat the question as a bug report, and go fix the opening.
Know who’s listening, and when to stop
Different listeners play different imaginary games, because they want different things from yours.
- Teammates imagine building it. They want something unusual they’d be proud of, a bit of a creative stretch, and actually possible, since they’re the ones who’ll have to make it work.
- People with money imagine the safe alternative, which is usually a sequel to last year’s hit. Your idea gets measured against that, and your record of finishing things does a lot of the talking.
- People who review games have heard every pitch there is. They want something that sounds new to them, and a reason to believe you can deliver it.
- Everybody else (a local paper, your aunt) needs a reason to care about a game at all. That usually means a second hook from outside games: the subject, the people, the story behind it.
A word on trends. Whatever’s fashionable this month, everyone else’s pitch mentions it too, and experienced listeners quietly discount it. Your idea should stand up with the trend taken out.
And energy matters more than people admit. If you sound half-interested in your own game, why should anyone be more interested than you?
The last skill is the hardest: stopping. A short pitch leaves blanks, and listeners fill blanks in their own favor. They picture each missing piece the way they’d enjoy it most. Keep talking after they’re sold and you start filling those blanks in yourself, sometimes with choices they like less than their own. That’s overselling, and it can unsell an idea you’d already sold. When you can see you’ve got them, stop talking. Smile. Maybe leave.
Pitching doesn’t end when people say yes, either. Every week you’ll be re-explaining where the game is headed to the people helping you make it. Level 20 calls that shared sense of direction a design vision, and keeping it alive is a pitch that never quite finishes.
Try it · Pocket Game, step 19Thirty seconds, three people
Write a pitch for your Pocket Game that you can say aloud in thirty seconds. Open with the hook and use the word “you” at least twice. Don’t name a genre. Say it to three people, one at a time, who haven’t seen the game. After each one, write down the first question they asked and the moment their attention dipped. Cut or change one thing before the next person. If anyone asks “why is that fun?”, rewrite your first line before you go on.
Carry forward: Say the thing that excited you, say it to the listener as “you,” and stop while they’re still imagining.