Lesson 4 · Part 2: The Player

Choices That Matter

Why choosing changes everything: agency, ownership, and the feelings you can only get by doing.

12 min read

Choices That Matter

Think of a route you’ve only ever traveled as a passenger. Maybe it’s the drive to a relative’s house, done every holiday for years with someone else at the wheel. Now imagine being handed the keys and told to get there on your own. Most people find they barely know the way. They sat through every turn and decided none of them.

Now think of a route you worked out yourself, once, in a strange city, with your phone on two percent. You can probably still remember the wrong turn, the bakery that saved you, and how good it felt to arrive. One trip, years ago, and it stuck. The difference wasn’t the road. It was who was choosing.

This lesson is about that difference: why a choice changes how a player feels about everything that follows, and how to tell a real choice from one that only looks like it.

The steering wheel

Many big adventure games save their most spectacular moments for cutscenes, the short films where the controls go dead and you watch. The bridge collapses, the hero leaps, the music swells. Then the controls come back and you have to make a much smaller jump yourself, and somehow that one is the jump you remember.

Will Wright, who designed SimCity and The Sims, puts it like this:

“It’s the difference between being on a roller coaster and being in a car behind the steering wheel.”

Will Wright

Everybody on a roller coaster gets the same ride, because the track decides. In a car, where you end up depends on what you did with the wheel. The word for what the driver has is agency: the power to make choices that change what happens next. It’s the one thing games have that books, films and music don’t.

You can feel the difference on a kitchen table. In Snakes and Ladders you roll, move, and climb or slide as the board tells you, and nobody makes a single decision all game. That isn’t because of the die. Plenty of games with dice are full of choices, and Level 10 shows how chance and choosing can work together. Snakes and Ladders just never asks you anything.

Agency needs two things to be real. The player has to have more than one thing they could sensibly do, and the world has to turn out differently depending on which one they pick. Lots of story games offer a menu of replies where every reply leads to the same next line. Players spot that quickly, and once they have, they stop reading the menu. Two doors that open onto the same room is a roller coaster with a steering wheel glued on.

Agency doesn’t mean unlimited freedom. A driver is still on a road, in a car with a top speed. What matters is that inside those limits the decisions are the driver’s, and they count.

Pick a path
Walk the farmer down the path. At each fork, tap the way you want to go. Try all three maps.

Choosing makes it yours

Something comes along with the wheel. If you chose to turn left, then where you ended up is your doing. Responsibility arrives with the choice, for bad results and good ones alike, and with responsibility comes a feeling that the result belongs to you. That feeling is ownership.

You can see it in how players treat failure. Celeste, a hard platform game about climbing a mountain, counts how many times you die, and players compare their death counts with something close to pride. Every one of those deaths came from a jump the player chose to make, so every one was theirs, and so is the summit when they finally reach it. A film that showed its hero falling off a cliff two thousand times would empty the cinema. When the failure is yours, it becomes an interesting failure instead, and you want another go. Level 5 is all about that.

There’s a principle hiding in here that sits under the whole of this part of the course. Player-centered design means starting from what the player does, decides and feels, and treating everything else (pictures, story, technology) as support for that. A designer isn’t putting on a show for an audience. A designer builds a road and a car and hands over the keys. Players differ in skill and in what they enjoy, so a player-centered game leaves room for each of them to drive it differently.

Whose fall was that?
Let the autopilot run the jungle, then switch to “You jump” and do it yourself. After each fall, say whose fall it was.

Feelings you can only get by doing

People sometimes say films move them and games leave them cold. A better way to see it is that the two draw on different sets of feelings. Designers call each set an emotional palette.

Film’s palette is built on empathy. The character grieves, and you’re sad. She wins, and you’re glad for her. The feelings are real, but they’re secondhand: you feel with someone. A game’s palette is built on agency. Because you did the thing, a game can give you feelings that need you to be the cause: pride, guilt, accomplishment, the warmth of having pulled your weight for your team.

Wright tells two stories about this. In Choplifter, an early-1980s game, you flew a little helicopter to rescue people about ten pixels high, and when you dropped them at the base they jumped out and waved at you. He remembers feeling proud, which is a lot to feel about ten white pixels. Years later, in Black & White, a game where you raise a giant creature and can reward or punish it, he slapped his creature just to see what would happen. It became downtrodden and sad, and he felt guilty, even though he knew it was software.

Neither moment needed lifelike pictures. Each game gave the player something to do, then showed them clearly what they had done. That’s good news for a beginner: you don’t need a big budget to make people feel something. You need them to act, and you need the world to answer, so the mental model they built in Level 3 can connect what happened to what they did.

Watch, then do
First watch the farmer bring the chickens in before dark. Then it’s your turn. Afterwards, pick a word for how each one felt.

When “it” becomes “me”

Almost any tool can become part of your body for a while. A telescope extends your eyes and a phone extends your voice. A car extends your legs, and cars show something odd: when another car dents your bumper, you don’t say “someone hit my car.” You say “someone hit me.”

Games do this too. Call it extension of self: the moment the thing a player controls stops being an object they operate and becomes, for now, part of who they are. Watch anyone play a racing game and they’ll lean into the corners, though the couch isn’t going anywhere. Board game players do it as well: “You landed on me.”

Wright noticed it while watching people play The Sims, a game about looking after a household of little people. Players started out describing their character from outside: he’s hungry, he’s going to the fridge. Within a few minutes, with no prompting, they’d shifted to I got tired, so I went to bed.

For a designer, this is a lever. The more directly the character answers the player’s hand, and the more the player has shaped it, the sooner “it” turns into “me.” After that, everything in the game happens to someone the player cares about.

Mind the apples
Apples keep dropping in the orchard. Watch the farmer wander for a while, then take the controls. A bonk costs nothing either way.
Try it · Pocket Game, step 4Real choices

Play one full turn of your Pocket Game slowly and write down every point where a player does something. Next to each, mark D if they had a real decision (two or more sensible options that lead to different results) or N if they were only following a rule. Cut or shorten the N steps wherever you can. Then add one new decision that matters: a risk to take or refuse, or a piece to protect or spend. Play again, and notice whether the turn now feels like yours.

Carry forward: Give the player the wheel, and make sure the road goes somewhere different when they turn it.

Check

Give it a wheel

A race game where nobody ever decides anything. For each new rule, decide: does it give the player a real choice?