In plain words
A toy is something that does something back when you play with it. It has behavior and no instructions. You cannot win or lose at a toy, because it never tells you what you are supposed to be doing.
See it
A spinning top. Flick it and it leans, drifts, wobbles, and recovers. It gives you plenty to watch and plenty to try, and it has no opinion about what counts as success.
Why designers care
Players are very good at turning toys into games all by themselves. If the toy underneath is satisfying to poke, people invent goals without being asked. If it’s dull, no scoring system will save it. So build and test the toy first.
Common mix-up
“Toy” is not an insult and does not mean “for children.” It names the responsive core that every good game has under its rules.