Lesson 1 · Part 1: Play

Play, Toys, and Games

What play is, how a toy becomes a game, and who decides what winning means.

12 min read

Play, Toys, and Games

Give a two-year-old a big cardboard box and watch what happens. First they knock on it. Then they climb in, and for a while it’s a car. Then it’s a boat, then a place to hide, then a drum. Nobody explained any of this to them, and nobody is keeping score.

Every game starts somewhere like that box: something that’s fun to mess about with, and a person deciding what to do with it. This lesson separates three words people often use as if they meant the same thing (play, toy and game), and looks at a question that matters more than it sounds: who decides what winning means?

Play

Video games start the same way. In the first minute after a new game loads, before you’ve read a single tutorial prompt, you’re pressing buttons to see what happens. You jump, then jump again to see how high it goes. You run at a wall to find out whether you can climb it, and walk into the water to check whether you’ll drown. Nobody asked you to, and nothing is keeping score. For that minute the game is a toy. Then it points you at something, like a door or a flag at the end of the level, and the toy becomes a game.

Play is trying things to see what happens, in a space where failing is cheap. Video games are very good at cheap failure. You fall into a pit, you’re back at the checkpoint a second later, and you know something you didn’t know before.

That cheapness is what makes play useful. When a mistake costs nothing, you make lots of them, and each one teaches you a little more about how the world works. Children playing house and kittens play-fighting are doing the same thing: practicing in a stand-in for the real thing, where getting it wrong doesn’t hurt.

Fall in, try again
Tap to start running, and tap again to jump the stream. Then switch to “Falling is costly” and run it again.

Toys

A toy is something that responds when you poke it, without telling you what to do. In a video game, the toy is everything you can touch: how your character moves, how high they jump, how a crate tumbles when you shove it.

Designers spend a lot of time on this part, often before any goal exists. A jump that feels floaty and vague gives you nothing to work with. A jump that’s quick and predictable, with a little hang time at the top, makes you want to jump again just to feel it. That’s a useful test for any toy: after you’ve tried something once, do you want to try it again?

Toy, then game
Get close to the chickens and watch them scatter. Then switch to ”+ Goal”, and then to ”+ Rule”. The chickens never change.

Games

When a goal shows up, the toy becomes a game. The definition this course uses is that a game is play with a goal, plus rules about how you’re allowed to reach it.

The rules matter as much as the goal. Getting chickens into a coop is easy if you can pick them up and carry them. The rule that you have to throw it from behind a line is what makes it worth trying. Every game works this way. Mario could finish a level much faster if he could walk through walls; the walls are the game.

Designers call the target a goal state: the situation the player is trying to bring about. Reaching the flagpole is a goal state. So is checkmate, and so is being the last player standing in a battle royale.

The walls are the game
Walk to the marked tile by the pool. Then switch the walls off and walk there again. Your footprints stay on the sand, so you can compare the two routes.

Who sets the goal?

The goal doesn’t have to come from the designer. Minecraft does have an ending, but plenty of players never look for it. They build castles, cities, and working computers out of blocks, and each of them is chasing a goal they made up. Speedrunners take games they’ve already finished and invent a new goal for them: finish as fast as possible, using routes and tricks the designers never planned.

Will Wright, who designed SimCity and The Sims, built his games around this idea. SimCity’s main mode has no win screen. Some players aim for a huge city, some for one with no traffic, some rebuild their own hometown.

“I’m giving the player a toy and the player is turning it into a game.”

Will Wright

Games built like this are called sandbox games: a space, a set of tools, and no fixed assignment. SimCity itself started as a toy. Wright had made a map editor for his first game, a helicopter game, and found he enjoyed building cities in the editor more than bombing them in the game.

A town with no goal
Build anything you like. The town won’t ask you for anything. Watch what happens anyway.

Does someone have to lose?

In a one-on-one fighting game, one player wins and the other loses. Count a win as +1 and a loss as −1, and the two results always add up to zero. That’s called a zero-sum game: whatever one player gains, the other loses.

Co-op games work differently. In Overcooked, a group of friends runs a chaotic restaurant kitchen together and shares one score. Nobody can win at someone else’s expense. Everyone at the table wins or loses together, and a good round lifts the whole team.

Versus or co-op?
Play a few rounds in each mode and watch the total.

Neither kind is better. Versus games give you rivalry and comebacks; co-op games give you teamwork and shared stories. What matters is choosing on purpose. Early in a design, ask whether someone has to lose for the game to be fun.

Where to start

Most people who want to make a game start with the story, the world, and the ending. Start with the toy instead. Get something on screen that’s satisfying to poke, hand it to someone, and watch what they try to do with it. If nobody invents a goal, adding rules won’t save it. If they invent five, your job becomes choosing one.

Make the jump feel good
Jump a few times with each feel. Which one makes you want to keep pressing?
Try it · Pocket Game, step 1Toy hunt

Collect about ten small objects from your pockets or a drawer: coins, paperclips, a bottle cap, a rubber band. Play with them for five minutes with no plan. When you notice you’re trying to do something specific, write it down: “I was trying to ___.” That’s your first goal, and those objects are your toy. Keep both. Over the next lessons you’ll turn them into a small game, because paper and pocket change are the fastest way to try a game idea.

Check

Who sets the goal?

For each one, decide who sets the goal: the game, or the player.