Lesson 15 · Part 5: Making It
Finding Ideas
Where game ideas come from when you stop staring at other games and start poking at everything else.
Finding Ideas
Pick up a rock. Any rock off a path or out of a parking lot will do. It looks like the least promising object on Earth.
Now hold it closer. That gray-green crust on one side is alive, a slow colony creeping outward a few millimeters a year. A different crust is working its way in from the other side, and someday the two are going to meet, and it will not be friendly. The sunny face stays dry. The shady face holds water. So you’ve got territory, a border war, and two climates on something the size of your fist, all running on a clock measured in decades.
Game designers like to say that almost anything, looked at the right way, can become something fascinating to play with. It sounds like an exaggeration until you try it with a rock. This level is about how to look.
Start with a subject, not a game
Here’s a strange thing about good game ideas: they rarely start as game ideas. Kids prove this every day. Nobody designed “don’t step on the cracks.” Somebody looked at a sidewalk, noticed the lines, and decided the lines were lava. The subject came first, and the game grew out of it.
Plenty of famous games began the same way. Chess grew out of war, with its kings and footsoldiers and the whole messy business of protecting a leader. Snakes and Ladders started out in India as a game about good deeds and bad ones, where virtues lift you up the board and vices slide you back down. The board game that became Monopoly was first designed to show people what happens when landlords own everything. Every one of these is a subject someone cared about, turned into something you could push around a table.
Will Wright, who made the city-building game SimCity, works this way on purpose. He doesn’t sit down to think up a game. He reads, widely and without a plan, until he trips over a subject that won’t leave him alone. SimCity came out of an engineer’s early computer models of how cities grow and decline. His ant game came out of a biologist’s books on how ant colonies work, where a single ant is a dim little robot and the colony as a whole is surprisingly clever. Most of those sources were dry, technical, and full of jargon. His ambition was to turn each one into a toy, something you could poke and watch respond.
He also has a test for which subjects are worth keeping, and it’s a good one. Most topics get duller the more you learn. A few get stranger and better with every layer you peel back. Those few are the ones worth months of your life.
Designers call the digging research, though it’s looser than the school kind. You’re soaking in a subject until you can feel how its parts push on each other. Chefs do this when they walk the market before writing the menu. Comedians do it when they notice the weird little rules of an airport queue. You’ll collect far more than you ever use, and that’s fine. Everything you soak up widens what you’re able to imagine later.
The genre box
Listen to how most people describe a game idea. “It’s that famous fantasy game, but on the moon.” “It’s like that puzzle game, but with cats.” The idea is defined entirely by how far it sits from something that already exists.
The usual shorthand for this is genre, a label for a family of games that play alike: puzzle games, racing games, word games, strategy games. You know the idea from books and films already, with whodunits, romcoms, and westerns. Genres are handy on a shelf, where you want to know roughly what you’re getting. As a place to start a design, though, a genre is a box, and thousands of people have already searched every corner of it.
Starting from a subject gets you out of the box without even trying. When you begin with ants or traffic or sleep, the game takes whatever shape the subject asks for. It may still end up looking like a familiar genre, and that’s fine, because you got there by a road nobody else took. The trap returns in Level 19, where a pitch that opens with a genre shrinks your idea in the listener’s head before you’ve finished the sentence.
Turn it around twenty times
Once a subject has its hooks in you, resist the urge to ask “so what’s the game?” right away. First, take the subject apart. What are its pieces? What happens to it over time? What’s the science underneath? What’s its history? Then ask a different kind of question. How would I like to see this? How would I want to hold it, change it, or build it? If it were a lump of clay, what tools would I want?
Each answer is one of many perspectives on the subject, a particular place to stand while you look at it. Take the rock again. You could zoom in until the crust is a jungle. You could speed up time and watch frost split the stone. You could be the crust, or the weather, or a collector who trades rare rocks. You could sell plots of rock surface to tiny settlers. Every one of those is a different game about the same rock.
Wright runs a subject through twenty or thirty perspectives like this. Most go nowhere. Two or three start to grip, and those are the ones he follows.
“I think the perspectives are far more valuable than particular solutions or approaches.”
Photographers know this feeling. Walk around a tree with a camera and you’ll find maybe two angles out of fifty that make it look like something. You don’t need fifty perspectives for your first game. You do need more than one, because the first answer that pops into your head is almost always the genre box again.
Get it into your hands
While a subject is still turning over in his head, Wright makes things. He draws pictures and builds physical models. Before the neighborhood in The Sims (a game about looking after little simulated people in their homes) existed in code, he built a small scale model of a few houses and their gardens, and the finished game ended up looking a lot like it. For his ant game he built a giant ant.
The principle is tangibility: giving an idea a shape you can touch, so your hands can do some of the thinking. Architects build foam models even though they could draw everything on a screen. Novelists pin index cards to a wall and shuffle them. Kids designing a board game at the kitchen table grab a cereal box and some buttons long before they’ve finished the rules. Something happens when you can pick an idea up. Your mind tilts a few degrees, and ideas show up that reading never produced.
It works even better once the thing responds. Wright says that the moment his first rough city simulation was running, his interest in urban planning went through the roof. Traffic modeling would’ve sounded mind-numbing a month earlier. With a little live city to tinker with, it was suddenly absorbing.
That’s the feeling you’re trying to hand to players, too. When people get to build and manipulate something, they feel ownership of it, and they start to care about subjects they’d never have read a book about. Making an idea playable early has its own name and its own level. It’s the prototype, and it’s next.
Follow what pulls you
All of this assumes you can tell which subject deserves your time. The honest answer is that you’ll go with your gut, and you should.
It’s very hard to design for an imagined stranger, guessing at what they think and want. It’s much easier to design for yourself, then work out why you’re enjoying it, then ask what would let someone else see it the same way. Your own curiosity is the one instrument you can read directly. If a subject keeps tugging at you, assume there’s a way to bring other people along.
So the advice is short. Follow the subject you keep coming back to. Stay off the genre shelf for a while. Get something you can hold.
Try it · Pocket Game, step 15Ten lenses
Pick a subject you’re curious about that has nothing to do with games: tides, bees, queues, your street, how bread rises. Spend ten minutes reading about it and jot down three facts that surprised you. Then write ten one-line perspectives, each starting “What if you were ___” or “What if you could ___.” Star the two that pull hardest. Now look at your Pocket Game. Either re-theme it around one starred perspective (rename the pieces and change one rule to fit), or tuck the starred line away as the seed of a second game.
Carry forward: Look at the world first and at other games second.